Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy

Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation recognizes the increasing integration of generative artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies into academic research and scholarly publishing. The journal allows the responsible application of these technologies as supplementary resources, provided that they do not replace human intellectual contributions, critical evaluation, academic judgment, or individual accountability.

This policy establishes requirements for authors, peer reviewers, and editors to maintain transparency, academic integrity, confidentiality, and ethical responsibility throughout the scholarly publication process.

1. Use of AI by Authors

Authors are permitted to utilize generative AI and AI-assisted technologies to support manuscript development and other academic activities, including:

  • Enhancing grammatical correctness, language quality, clarity, and readability.

  • Assisting in the arrangement, improvement, and restructuring of manuscript content.

  • Facilitating literature searches and identifying relevant academic sources and information.

  • Supporting brainstorming activities and the preliminary organization and synthesis of ideas.

  • Assisting with programming, computational processes, and data analysis, provided that all outputs are properly examined and verified.

  • Undertaking other supplementary activities under appropriate human supervision and control.

Regardless of the AI applications employed, authors remain fully accountable for the entire manuscript. They must ensure that all AI-generated or AI-assisted content is accurate, comprehensive, impartial, original, and consistent with recognized scholarly standards. Particular attention must be given to examining references generated by AI systems, as they may contain inaccurate bibliographic information or identify sources that do not actually exist.

Authors are required to:

  1. Carefully examine and independently verify all content generated or supported by artificial intelligence tools.

  2. Ensure that every citation and reference corresponds to an authentic, accessible, and academically relevant source.

  3. Verify the accuracy of factual statements, statistical information, quotations, and research interpretations.

  4. Ensure that the manuscript reflects the authors' own intellectual contributions, critical reasoning, and academic judgment.

  5. Protect confidential, personal, proprietary, and unpublished information when utilizing AI-based services.

  6. Ensure that AI-generated content accounts for no more than 20% of the total manuscript and explicitly confirm compliance with this requirement in the originality statement.

  7. Comply with applicable copyright laws, intellectual property regulations, data protection requirements, and research ethics principles.

Full accountability for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of all submitted manuscript content rests with the authors rather than the artificial intelligence systems or technologies they employ.

2. AI-Generated or Fabricated References

Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation emphasizes that all references included in submitted manuscripts must satisfy established standards of academic accuracy, authenticity, and verifiability. Authors are responsible for verifying every cited source to establish its existence, bibliographic correctness, relevance, and consistency with the arguments or statements it is intended to support.

The use of fabricated, nonexistent, substantially inaccurate, or misleading references, including those produced by AI applications, may be regarded as a serious breach of publication ethics. Authors are encouraged to provide valid and accessible Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs) or other persistent identification codes for cited sources whenever available.

The editorial team reserves the right to verify references at different stages of the publication process, including initial manuscript screening, peer review, and final manuscript preparation.

Submissions containing fabricated references, systematically unverifiable sources, or AI-generated content exceeding the journal's maximum permitted limit of 20% may be rejected or excluded from further publication consideration.

If such violations are discovered after an article has been published, the journal may implement appropriate corrective measures, including issuing corrections or retracting the article, in accordance with its established publication ethics policies.

3. Disclosure of AI Use

Authors must provide a clear declaration whenever generative AI or AI-assisted technologies have been substantially involved in manuscript preparation. The disclosure must contain the following information:

  • The name of the artificial intelligence tool, application, or service employed.

  • The intended purpose and extent of its application in preparing the manuscript.

  • Confirmation that all AI-generated or AI-assisted materials have been examined and independently verified by the authors.

  • An explicit acknowledgment that the authors retain full responsibility for the manuscript and its contents.

Declaration of Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies

In preparing this manuscript, the author(s) utilized [NAME OF TOOL/SERVICE] for [PURPOSE OF USE]. All resulting content generated or supported by the tool was subsequently reviewed, verified, and revised by the author(s). The author(s) accept full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, academic integrity, and final content of the manuscript.

This declaration must be incorporated into the originality statement whenever substantial assistance from generative AI or AI-assisted technologies has been utilized. Authors who have not made substantial use of these technologies in preparing their manuscripts are not required to provide such a declaration.

4. AI as an Author or Co-Author

Artificial intelligence applications, including generative AI systems and large language models, cannot be recognized or listed as authors or co-authors of scholarly publications. Authorship requires the capacity to examine and approve the final manuscript, assume responsibility for the entire work, maintain research integrity, and respond to questions or concerns regarding the published content. These responsibilities can only be fulfilled by human contributors.

Accordingly, any assistance provided by artificial intelligence must be appropriately acknowledged or disclosed in accordance with this policy and must not be represented as an authorship contribution.

5. Use of AI in Research Methodology

When artificial intelligence is utilized as an integral component of the research methodology, rather than merely as an instrument for assisting manuscript preparation, its specific application must be clearly explained in the Methods section. Authors must provide sufficient methodological information to enable readers to understand the procedures, evaluate their appropriateness, and reproduce the research process whenever applicable.

Depending on the nature and requirements of the research, authors should provide the following information:

  • The name of the artificial intelligence tool, application, or model employed.

  • The specific version or release of the AI system utilized.

  • The identity of the developer or service provider.

  • The intended purpose and operational function of the AI system within the research process.

  • Relevant procedures, system configurations, or prompts necessary to support methodological reproducibility.

  • The procedures implemented by human researchers to review, validate, and verify AI-generated outputs.

  • Other methodological information necessary to evaluate the validity and reliability of the research findings.

The integration of artificial intelligence into research methodology is not prohibited in itself. However, its application must be transparently disclosed, appropriately documented, and sufficiently reproducible in accordance with the characteristics and requirements of the research design.

6. AI-Generated Figures, Images, and Data Visualizations

The use of artificial intelligence to fabricate, falsify, manipulate, or misrepresent research data, observations, or empirical findings is strictly prohibited.

AI-assisted visual representations may be incorporated into manuscripts provided that they accurately reflect authentic underlying data and are generated through transparent and reproducible analytical or computational procedures. Any substantial use of AI in producing explanatory illustrations, conceptual frameworks, diagrams, research workflows, or other supporting visual materials must be explicitly disclosed.

Authors bear full responsibility for ensuring that all figures, images, tables, and data visualizations included in their manuscripts are accurate, genuinely original where originality is claimed, ethically appropriate, and compliant with applicable copyright laws and intellectual property regulations.

7. Use of AI by Reviewers

All manuscripts submitted to Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation must be treated as strictly confidential documents. Reviewers are prohibited from uploading, copying, transferring, or disclosing submitted manuscripts or any confidential portions thereof to publicly accessible or otherwise unauthorized artificial intelligence platforms.

This restriction applies to, but is not limited to, the following materials:

  • Complete manuscripts or substantial excerpts of submitted articles.

  • Abstracts containing unpublished research information.

  • Tables, figures, and supplementary materials.

  • Unpublished research datasets and findings.

  • Confidential information obtained throughout the peer-review process.

These restrictions are intended to safeguard authors' intellectual property rights, maintain manuscript confidentiality, and protect the privacy of research-related information.

Artificial intelligence tools must not replace the independent academic judgment and professional expertise of reviewers. Reviewers remain personally responsible for:

  • Evaluating the academic quality, originality, and scholarly merit of submitted manuscripts.

  • Assessing the manuscript's contribution to the fields of Islamic education and educational innovation.

  • Examining the appropriateness, validity, and methodological rigor of the research procedures.

  • Identifying the manuscript's strengths, limitations, and aspects requiring further improvement.

  • Providing impartial, constructive, and evidence-based recommendations.

  • Ensuring that all review reports are accurate, objective, professionally presented, and respectful.

AI-generated assessments must never be regarded as substitutes for reviewers' independent critical evaluations or be allowed to determine editorial recommendations without the reviewer's own assessment.

Limited AI assistance may be permitted for supplementary activities, such as improving the language and readability of a review report already prepared by the reviewer or exploring general academic background literature. Such assistance is acceptable only when no confidential manuscript information is disclosed to AI platforms and all applicable confidentiality and ethical requirements are strictly maintained.