Corrections and Retractions Policy

Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation is committed to safeguarding the accuracy, credibility, and integrity of the scholarly record. Whenever errors, ethical issues, or instances of research misconduct are identified in published articles, the journal takes appropriate and timely measures to address them in a transparent manner. This policy is developed with reference to the Retraction Guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the relevant NISO Recommended Practice concerning retracted scholarly publications.

1. Guiding Principles

The journal adheres to the following fundamental principles when addressing issues arising after publication:

  • Preservation of the Scholarly Record: Published articles are generally maintained in the journal's archives. Any corrections, expressions of concern, or retraction notices are connected to the corresponding articles to ensure that changes to the scholarly record remain transparent and traceable.

  • Accuracy and Integrity: Actions taken after publication are intended to preserve the reliability of scholarly literature and should not be regarded as punitive measures in themselves.

  • Timely Action: The editorial team endeavors to address reported errors and concerns within a reasonable timeframe to prevent misleading information from continuing to circulate.

  • Transparency: All correction notices, expressions of concern, and retraction statements must be publicly available and clearly communicate the reasons underlying the actions taken.

2. Types of Post-Publication Actions

a. Correction

A correction is issued when an article contains an error that does not invalidate its primary findings or conclusions. Depending on the origin of the error, corrections may take the following forms:

  • Erratum: Issued to rectify mistakes introduced by the journal during editorial handling, typesetting, or publication. Examples include misspelled author names, incorrect institutional affiliations, or tables that were inadvertently omitted.

  • Corrigendum: Published to correct errors originating from the author(s), such as inaccurate citations, mistakes in data reporting that do not affect the conclusions, or incomplete disclosures concerning funding and conflicts of interest.

Corrections are published as independent notices and assigned separate DOIs where applicable. Each correction notice must contain a link to the original article, while the original publication must also provide a corresponding link to the correction. When necessary, the original article may be updated, provided that the modification is accompanied by a clear explanation of the correction and its publication date.

b. Expression of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when significant doubts arise regarding the reliability of an article, the integrity of the research, or compliance with ethical standards, but the available evidence is not yet sufficient to establish a definitive conclusion.

Such circumstances may include:

  • An investigation conducted by the journal, the author's affiliated institution, or another relevant organization is still in progress.

  • The available evidence has not yet established whether the reported findings can be considered reliable.

  • Reasonable concerns exist regarding the completeness, objectivity, or progress of the ongoing investigation.

The expression of concern must be linked to the original article and remain publicly accessible while the matter is being examined. Once the investigation has been completed, the journal may issue a correction or retraction, or withdraw the expression of concern if the allegations are determined to be unfounded.

c. Retraction

A retraction is issued when the findings, conclusions, or overall integrity of a published article can no longer be regarded as sufficiently reliable. Grounds for retraction may include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • Clear evidence of fabricated or falsified research data, survey responses, interview findings, classroom observations, or other research materials.

  • Significant errors in research design, data analysis, or interpretation that invalidate the principal findings or conclusions.

  • Plagiarism, including substantial unattributed copying or undisclosed reuse of previously published text.

  • Duplicate or redundant publication without appropriate disclosure or justification.

  • Serious breaches of research ethics, including failure to obtain required informed consent or appropriate ethical approval for studies involving students, teachers, or other human participants.

  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest that substantially compromise the reliability or integrity of the published work.

  • Manipulation of authorship arrangements, peer-review procedures, or the editorial process.

  • Unauthorized acquisition, use, or disclosure of research data, educational materials, images, or other content, as well as violations of applicable intellectual property rights.

Retraction may also be considered in other circumstances involving serious breaches of publication ethics that substantially undermine confidence in the published article.

d. Removal of an Article

Removing an article from the journal's website is reserved for exceptional situations in which continued public access may create serious legal, ethical, or safety-related risks.

Examples of circumstances that may justify removal include:

  • The article contains material that clearly infringes legal rights, including defamatory statements or content.

  • Removal is necessary to comply with a valid court order or another legally binding requirement.

  • The publication exposes confidential information that places a research participant, student, teacher, or other individual at significant risk.

When removal becomes necessary, the journal will retain the article's bibliographic information, including its title, authors, and DOI, wherever legally permissible. A public notice will explain the removal, subject to any applicable legal restrictions.

e. Replacement of an Article

Under exceptional circumstances involving a serious but unintentional error that can be corrected by the authors, the journal may consider publishing a revised replacement article when the necessary corrections substantially affect the original findings or conclusions.

Where appropriate, the original article will be formally retracted, and the corrected version will be published as a separate article. A retraction notice must explain the reasons for the replacement and establish clear links between the original publication, the retraction notice, and the corrected version to maintain an accurate publication history.

3. Retraction Procedure

The journal manages retraction cases through a systematic, fair, and properly documented process.

Initiation: A retraction process may be initiated following a request from the authors or independently by the editorial team in response to a post-publication report, an allegation of research misconduct, or findings resulting from an institutional or independent investigation.

Investigation: The editorial team examines the available evidence in accordance with COPE recommendations and the journal's Research Misconduct Policy. The authors concerned must be given a reasonable opportunity to respond to the allegations and the supporting evidence.

Decision: The Editor-in-Chief determines the appropriate action by considering the available evidence, the authors' explanations, and any relevant findings provided by experts or affiliated institutions. Wherever practicable, the journal will seek the authors' agreement regarding the wording of the retraction notice. However, the absence of such agreement does not prevent the journal from proceeding with a justified retraction.

Publication of the Notice: The retraction statement will be published online as soon as reasonably possible and included in a subsequent journal issue where applicable. A separate DOI will be assigned when supported by the journal's publishing infrastructure.

4. Requirements for a Retraction Notice

Every retraction notice issued by Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation must fulfill the following requirements:

  • Use the prescribed title format: "Retraction: [Original Article Title]".

  • Clearly identify the authors and provide complete bibliographic information for the original article.

  • Include a direct link to the original publication, while ensuring that the original article also contains a link to the retraction notice.

  • Present the reasons for retraction in clear and factual language, distinguishing honest mistakes from research misconduct whenever the available evidence allows.

  • Specify whether the retraction was initiated by the authors, the editorial team, or another relevant party.

  • Employ objective, professional, and non-defamatory language throughout the notice.

  • Ensure that the retraction notice is freely accessible to all readers.

5. Status of Retracted Articles

To preserve the integrity, transparency, and traceability of the scholarly record, retracted articles will ordinarily remain available on the journal's website with a clear indication of their retracted status.

Where technically supported, the journal will implement the following measures:

  • Display a prominent "RETRACTED" label on the article's webpage and PDF document.

  • Establish reciprocal links between the original article and its corresponding retraction notice.

  • Inform Crossref and relevant indexing or abstracting services, where applicable, to facilitate updates to the article's publication status and bibliographic metadata.

An original article will not normally be removed solely because it has been retracted. Any exceptional decision to remove an article will be governed by the provisions established in this policy.

6. Withdrawal Before Publication

Withdrawal is different from retraction because it applies to manuscripts that have not yet been formally published as journal articles.

  • Before Acceptance: Authors may request manuscript withdrawal by submitting a written explanation to the editorial team. The request must receive approval from all co-authors.

  • After Acceptance but Before Publication: Withdrawal requests will only be considered when supported by valid and substantiated reasons and must obtain approval from the Editor-in-Chief.

  • During Peer Review: Authors are prohibited from submitting the same manuscript to another journal while it remains under consideration by Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation. Submission to another publication may only proceed after the editorial team has provided written confirmation that the withdrawal has been approved.

The journal reserves the right to request further explanations or supporting information when necessary to ensure that the withdrawal does not violate publication ethics or infringe upon the rights of other contributors.

7. Article Processing Charges

Article Processing Charges (APCs), where applicable, are generally non-refundable when an article is retracted due to errors, ethical violations, or research misconduct attributable to the author(s). However, corrections arising exclusively from mistakes introduced by the journal during editorial processing or publication will be implemented without imposing additional costs on the authors.

Any exceptional circumstances concerning publication fees will be evaluated in accordance with the applicable policies established by the publisher.

8. Appeals

Authors who disagree with a decision to issue a correction, publish an expression of concern, or retract an article may submit a formal written appeal to the Editor-in-Chief within 30 days of receiving the official notification.

The appeal must provide clear and reasonable grounds for reconsideration, supported by new evidence, relevant documentation, or substantial arguments that were not adequately addressed during the original assessment. Wherever practicable, the appeal will be evaluated by an independent editor or another qualified individual who was not directly involved in the initial decision.

The journal will formally communicate the outcome of the appeal to the relevant parties. The decision reached through the appeal process will ordinarily constitute the journal's final editorial determination concerning the matter.