Research Misconduct Policy

Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation is committed to safeguarding the integrity, credibility, and dependability of the scholarly record. The journal regards every allegation of research or publication misconduct as a serious concern, whether it involves manuscripts currently undergoing editorial assessment or articles that have already been published. All reported cases will be examined in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies and the applicable guidelines and flowcharts established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

1. Types of Research and Publication Misconduct

Research and publication misconduct encompasses various forms of unethical academic practices, including, but not limited to, the following:

  • Fabrication: Creating fictitious research data, survey responses, interview transcripts, classroom observations, experimental outcomes, or other research findings and presenting them as authentic results.

  • Falsification: Altering, manipulating, or selectively excluding research data, procedures, images, or findings in ways that distort or misrepresent the actual research outcomes.

  • Plagiarism: Incorporating another individual's ideas, statements, data, or intellectual work without providing appropriate acknowledgment or citation. This also includes undisclosed text recycling and self-plagiarism.

  • Duplicate or Redundant Publication: Publishing identical or substantially overlapping scholarly work in more than one publication without adequate disclosure, explanation, or justification.

  • Authorship Misconduct: Engaging in ghost authorship, gift or honorary authorship, or guest authorship, as well as making unauthorized additions, removals, or modifications to the author list without the appropriate approval and consent.

  • Citation Manipulation: Deliberately incorporating excessive, irrelevant, or strategically selected references to artificially increase citation frequencies or improperly influence bibliometric indicators.

  • Peer-Review Manipulation: Submitting false reviewer identities, attempting to evaluate one's own manuscript, interfering with the independence of the peer-review process, or disclosing confidential information obtained during manuscript evaluation.

  • Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest: Concealing or failing to declare financial, professional, institutional, or personal interests that may compromise the objectivity of research activities or their evaluation.

  • Violations of Research Ethics: Conducting research involving students, teachers, parents, or other human participants without appropriate ethical safeguards, obtaining informed consent when required, or adequately protecting participants' privacy and confidential information.

  • Misuse of Research Data: Obtaining, processing, utilizing, or disclosing personal or confidential educational information without proper authorization or in violation of applicable ethical principles and legal requirements.

  • Undisclosed or Inappropriate AI Use: Employing generative artificial intelligence or AI-assisted technologies in ways that contradict the journal's AI Policy, including concealing substantial AI involvement when disclosure is mandatory or presenting fabricated AI-generated information as authentic research data or evidence.

2. Reporting Suspected Misconduct

Any individual or institution, including authors, readers, peer reviewers, editors, and research organizations, may submit a report concerning suspected research or publication misconduct.

Reports must be directed to the Editor-in-Chief through the email address eternaedu@gmail.com, using the subject line "Allegation of Research Misconduct".

Where available, the report should contain the following information:

  • The title of the manuscript or published article, together with its Digital Object Identifier (DOI), if applicable.

  • A clear and detailed description of the suspected misconduct.

  • Relevant supporting documentation, such as original publications, comparative materials, research records, related correspondence, or other evidence that can be independently verified.

  • The name and contact information of the individual submitting the report.

Anonymous submissions may be taken into consideration when they provide sufficient and verifiable evidence to justify further examination. Nevertheless, insufficient identifying information or supporting documentation may limit the journal's ability to conduct a comprehensive investigation.

3. Confidentiality and Protection of Parties

All allegations will be managed confidentially to the greatest extent reasonably possible while ensuring that the investigation remains fair and impartial. The identity of the reporting individual will be protected and will not be disclosed to the person concerned without consent, except when disclosure is necessary to ensure procedural fairness or is required by applicable regulations.

Individuals accused of misconduct must be provided with a reasonable opportunity to present explanations and respond to the allegations. No individual will be considered responsible for misconduct until the available evidence has been properly examined and evaluated.

Reports submitted in bad faith, particularly those involving deliberately false allegations or intentionally misleading evidence, may also be examined in accordance with the journal's applicable policies.

4. Investigation Procedure

Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation implements a systematic procedure for examining allegations of research or publication misconduct. The investigation involves the following stages:

Initial Assessment: Upon receiving an allegation, the Editor-in-Chief acknowledges the report and evaluates whether the matter falls within the journal's authority and responsibilities. The available information is also examined to determine whether sufficient grounds exist to proceed with further investigation.

Evidence Collection: The editorial team examines the relevant submitted manuscript or published article and collects supporting evidence. Where appropriate, the journal may utilize verification instruments, including similarity-detection software and reference-authentication procedures, to assist in assessing the allegation.

Author Response: The corresponding author is formally informed of the concerns raised and provided with a specified period to explain the circumstances and respond to the allegations and supporting evidence.

Evaluation: The editorial team reviews and assesses the available evidence together with the explanation provided by the author. When additional expertise is required, the journal may consult independent specialists, editorial board members, or relevant COPE recommendations to support an objective evaluation.

Referral to Relevant Institutions: When an allegation is serious, the available evidence indicates possible misconduct, or the journal does not possess sufficient authority to establish the underlying facts, the author's affiliated institution or relevant research funding organization may be contacted and requested to conduct an investigation.

Final Decision: The Editor-in-Chief determines the appropriate editorial measures based on the evidence examined, the author's response, and any relevant findings or recommendations obtained from independent experts or institutions. The final outcome is subsequently communicated to the relevant parties.

5. Possible Outcomes and Corrective Actions

The corrective measures or sanctions imposed will depend on the nature, severity, and potential consequences of the identified misconduct.

For manuscripts that are still undergoing editorial assessment, the journal may take the following actions:

  • Request additional explanations, supporting evidence, or necessary revisions to address the identified concerns.

  • Temporarily suspend the editorial evaluation process while the allegation is being investigated.

  • Reject the manuscript when the violation has been substantiated or when the reliability and integrity of the manuscript cannot be adequately established.

For articles that have already been published, the journal may implement the following measures:

  • Correction or Amendment: Issue an official correction or amendment when the identified problem can be resolved without compromising the overall reliability and integrity of the published article.

  • Expression of Concern: Publish a formal expression of concern when significant questions regarding the article remain unresolved while further investigation is being conducted.

  • Retraction: Withdraw the published article when its findings or overall content can no longer be considered reliable, or when the seriousness of the misconduct justifies formal retraction.

Retraction notices will be formally linked to the original publication. Where appropriate, the original article will remain accessible but will be clearly identified as retracted to maintain transparency and prevent its continued presentation as a reliable scholarly source.

Additional measures may include notifying the author's affiliated institution or research funding organization and imposing restrictions on future manuscript submissions for a specified period when justified by the circumstances.

Unintentional errors made in good faith that do not constitute misconduct and do not compromise the principal findings will generally be addressed through appropriate corrections rather than punitive measures.

6. Allegations Involving Editors or Reviewers

Allegations involving editors, peer reviewers, or other individuals participating in the editorial process will be addressed according to the same principles of fairness, confidentiality, and impartial evaluation applied to other misconduct cases.

Any editor who has a direct connection with the allegation must withdraw from the investigation and related decision-making procedures. If the allegation concerns the Editor-in-Chief, the matter will be referred to an independent senior member of the editorial board or the publisher, Eternaedu Publisher, for appropriate examination and resolution.

7. Appeals

Authors who disagree with a decision resulting from a research or publication misconduct investigation may submit a formal written appeal to the Editor-in-Chief within 30 days of receiving the official notification of the decision.

The appeal must clearly state the reasons for requesting reconsideration and include relevant new evidence, supplementary documentation, or substantial arguments that were not adequately examined or taken into account during the initial assessment.

Wherever practicable, appeals will be evaluated by an independent editor or another suitably qualified individual who was not directly involved in the original investigation or decision. The outcome of the appeal will be formally communicated to the relevant parties and will ordinarily constitute the journal's final editorial decision concerning the case.