Conflict of Interest Policy

Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation requires all parties participating in the scholarly publishing process, including authors, peer reviewers, and editors, to declare any existing, potential, or reasonably perceived conflicts of interest. Full disclosure is essential to ensuring the objectivity of editorial decisions, preserving the credibility of the peer-review process, and allowing readers to assess published articles independently and fairly. This policy is implemented in accordance with the applicable principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

1. Definition of Conflict of Interest

A conflict of interest refers to any financial, professional, institutional, personal, or intellectual interest or relationship that may affect, or reasonably be perceived as affecting, an individual's impartiality when preparing, evaluating, reviewing, or making editorial decisions concerning a manuscript. The presence of a conflict of interest does not automatically constitute unethical conduct. However, failure to disclose relevant competing interests may compromise the transparency and integrity of the scholarly publication process.

Examples of conflicts of interest that may arise in educational and Islamic education research include:

  • Financial Interests: Research funding, consultancy payments, honoraria, employment relationships, or other financial benefits received from organizations that may gain advantages from the findings, interpretations, or recommendations presented in an article.

  • Professional Interests: Participation in the design, development, implementation, or assessment of educational programs, Islamic teaching approaches, learning methodologies, assessment instruments, or educational technologies examined in the manuscript.

  • Institutional Interests: Professional or organizational affiliations with schools, universities, Islamic educational institutions, government agencies, publishers, or other organizations whose policies, programs, activities, or interests are discussed in the article.

  • Personal Relationships: Close family connections, friendships, personal disagreements, or other relationships with authors or individuals whose academic work, contributions, or research activities are discussed or evaluated in the manuscript.

2. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are required to disclose all actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may be associated with their submitted manuscripts. Such disclosures must be presented in a dedicated Conflict of Interest Statement, positioned at the end of the manuscript immediately before the References section.

In addition, authors must:

  • Identify and disclose all financial and non-financial sources of support through a Funding Statement. Where relevant, the disclosure should explain the funder's involvement in research planning and design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, and the decision to publish.

  • Explicitly state whether any conflicts of interest exist, including when no competing interests have been identified.

  • Immediately notify the editorial team if a previously undisclosed conflict of interest is discovered after manuscript submission or publication.

The following declaration formats may be used according to the relevant circumstances:

a. Declaration of No Conflict of Interest

Conflict of Interest: The authors confirm that they have no financial, professional, personal, or institutional conflicts of interest associated with this article.

b. Disclosure of a Relevant Interest

Conflict of Interest: The author is affiliated with an educational institution involved in the implementation of the program examined in this article. This affiliation has been appropriately disclosed and taken into consideration when interpreting the research findings.

c. Funding Disclosure

Funding: This work received financial support from [name of funding institution] under grant number [grant number]. The funding institution had no involvement in the research design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, or decision to publish, unless otherwise explicitly stated.

3. Responsibilities of Reviewers

Peer reviewers are expected to assess submitted manuscripts independently, impartially, and confidentially. They must decline an invitation to review or immediately inform the editorial team if an actual or potential conflict of interest could affect, or reasonably be perceived as affecting, their ability to provide an objective assessment.

Circumstances that may constitute a conflict of interest include:

  • Having a close personal, professional, or financial relationship with one or more of the manuscript's authors.

  • Having jointly published academic work with an author, served as their supervisor, or been supervised by them within the preceding three years.

  • Being employed in the same department, research group, or institutional unit as an author when such an affiliation could compromise the reviewer's impartiality.

  • Maintaining a direct financial, professional, or institutional interest in the educational program, intervention, technology, policy, or research findings being evaluated in the manuscript.

  • Holding strong personal or professional views that may prevent an objective and balanced assessment of the submitted work.

  • Being involved in any other circumstances that could reasonably raise concerns regarding the reviewer's independence and objectivity.

Reviewers are strictly prohibited from using confidential information obtained during the peer-review process for personal interests, professional benefits, or the advantage of any other individual or organization.

4. Responsibilities of Editors

Editors must disclose any relevant conflicts of interest and refrain from managing manuscripts whenever their impartiality or independence may be compromised. In such circumstances, the manuscript must be assigned to an independent editor who has no conflicting interests.

The following principles govern editorial responsibilities:

Submissions from Editorial Team Members: Manuscripts submitted by editors or other members of the editorial team must undergo the same initial editorial assessment and peer-review procedures applied to all other submissions. An editor submitting their own manuscript must not participate in its editorial management, reviewer selection, evaluation, or final publication decision. The submitting editor must also be denied access to confidential information concerning the review process beyond information that is appropriately made available to authors.

Submissions from Affiliated Institutions: When a manuscript is submitted by an author affiliated with the journal's publisher or an institution closely connected to the editorial team, the journal must implement appropriate measures to maintain independent editorial management and impartial peer review. Wherever possible, the evaluation should involve editors and reviewers from institutions that have no relevant professional or organizational connections with the submitting author.

Objectivity in Editorial Decisions: Editorial decisions must be determined by the manuscript's originality, academic quality, methodological soundness, relevance to the journal's aims and scope, and contribution to knowledge in Islamic education and educational innovation. Such decisions must not be improperly influenced by authors' institutional affiliations, nationality, gender, religion, political perspectives, or commercial interests.

5. Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest

When a previously undeclared conflict of interest is discovered during the peer-review process or after publication, Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation will examine the matter in accordance with its publication ethics policies and research misconduct procedures, while taking relevant recommendations from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) into consideration.

Depending on the nature and seriousness of the identified issue, the journal may require additional disclosures, issue an official correction, reassess the previous editorial decision, or retract the published article if the undisclosed conflict substantially affects the reliability or integrity of the published work. Notification to the relevant institutions may also be undertaken when considered necessary.

Eduvance: Journal of Islamic Education and Innovation is committed to addressing all cases involving conflicts of interest through fair, transparent, and consistent procedures to maintain public confidence in Islamic education research and the scholarly publishing process.